A Puppy Tells You Almost Nothing

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

People want to know what a puppy will become, and the honest answer is that the puppy does not show it yet. Almost every character used to identify an adult dog develops after the age at which puppies are rehomed.

What has not developed

Coat. Puppy coat is soft and often a different length and texture from the adult coat that replaces it between four and twelve months. Wire coats in particular look nothing like their adult form.

Colour. Many breeds change substantially. Black puppies go grey or silver; some breeds are born dark and lighten; Dalmatians are born white with no spots at all.

Ear carriage. Pricked-ear breeds go through months of ears rising, falling and rising again, often during teething. Ear set is not settled until around six months.

Proportion. Puppies are relatively large-headed and short-legged, and grow into their proportions at different rates depending on eventual size.

Muzzle. Short in every puppy. Whether a dog is long-muzzled or flat-faced becomes apparent over months.

Character Settles by
Coat texture 4–12 months
Adult colour 6–18 months in changing breeds
Ear carriage 6 months
Body proportion 8–18 months, later in large breeds
Adult height 8 months small, 18+ months giant
Adult weight 12 months small, 2 years giant

Why puppies converge

Selection acted on adult animals, so puppy appearance was largely unselected. Across many breeds, puppies retain a similar juvenile form — rounded skull, short muzzle, large eyes, soft coat — and the breed-specific adult form emerges afterwards.

That is why a litter photograph is such poor evidence, and why shelter staff assessing eight-week-old puppies are guessing more than they are with adults.

Size estimation

Covered in size and build, and worth restating here: the common rules are approximations that work for medium dogs and fail at the extremes.

A vet can assess growth plate closure on an x-ray, which is more informative and is rarely worth doing purely to satisfy curiosity.

What a puppy does show

Chondrodystrophy. Very short legs relative to body length is visible early and does not change, and it carries the disc-disease risk described elsewhere.

Flat face. A markedly shortened muzzle is apparent from the start and has real consequences for breathing and heat tolerance, as flat-faced dogs covers.

Dewclaws, tail length and obvious structural features, though a bobbed tail may be natural or docked and the two are not distinguishable by looking.

The practical position

If you are choosing a puppy of unknown parentage, choose on the basis that its adult size and appearance are uncertain, and that a range of outcomes is possible. Where that uncertainty is not acceptable, a known-parentage puppy or an adult dog removes it — an adult is what it is.

A DNA test at any age gives ancestry, and what dog DNA tests get right covers how much confidence to place in the result.

Litters are not uniform

Puppies in one litter can differ substantially, particularly in a mixed litter, because each puppy draws a different sample of its parents' genes. Coat, colour, size and ear set can all vary between siblings.

That is worth saying because people assume the puppy they meet will resemble its littermates as adults, and frequently it does not. Where a mother is visible and the father is unknown, the litter can end up looking like several different crosses.

Photographs age badly

A photograph of a puppy is a poor basis for a later identification, and shelter records built on them mislead. If you want a record that will still be useful, photograph the same dog at six months and a year — that pair of images carries far more information than a dozen taken at eight weeks.

Breeds referenced

Keep reading