The Small Birds That Come and Go All Day
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
These are the birds most people watch most, and they are separated by behaviour more easily than by plumage.
Chickadees
Small, round, with a black cap and bib and white cheeks. Active, vocal, and remarkably tame — often the first garden bird to take food from a hand.
The behaviour at a feeder is distinctive: they arrive, take a single seed, and leave with it to open it elsewhere or cache it. They do not sit and feed.
Black-capped and Carolina chickadees are nearly identical and are separated mainly by range and by voice, with a zone of overlap where the two hybridise and even experts hesitate.
Titmice
Larger, grey above and pale below, with a pointed crest, a black forehead patch and a warm buff wash along the flanks.
They behave like large chickadees — the same one-seed-at-a-time pattern, the same restless movement — and the two families travel together through winter.
The crest is the fast identifier and is visible at any distance the bird can be seen at.
Nuthatches
Compact, short-tailed, with a long straight bill and a blue-grey back. The white-breasted has a white face and black crown; the red-breasted is smaller, with a black eye line and rusty underparts.
The behaviour is unique: they walk down tree trunks head-first, which nothing else in the garden does. A bird descending a trunk face-down is a nuthatch and needs no further checking.
| Bird | Movement | Key mark |
|---|---|---|
| Chickadee | Hops, hangs, takes one seed | Black cap and bib |
| Titmouse | As chickadee, larger | Grey crest |
| White-breasted nuthatch | Head-first down trunks | White face, black crown |
| Red-breasted nuthatch | As above, smaller | Black eye line, rusty below |
| Brown creeper | Spirals up, then flies to the next trunk | Cryptic brown, curved bill |
| Carolina wren | Skulks low, tail cocked | Loud voice, white eyebrow |
The mixed winter flock
Through winter these species move together in loose flocks, often with a downy woodpecker, a brown creeper and a kinglet or two.
There is a reason: more eyes watching for predators, and the chickadees' alarm calls are used by the whole group. Learning the chickadee alarm — more dee notes for a more dangerous predator — is a genuinely useful skill, because it announces a hawk before the hawk is visible.
Finding one of these flocks in winter woodland usually means finding six species in five minutes, and it is far more productive than searching quiet woods.
Wrens, which are not in this group
Carolina wrens are frequently lumped in because they are small, active and visit feeders. They are longer-billed, warm brown, with a bold white eyebrow and a cocked tail, and they skulk in low cover rather than working through the canopy.
They are also astonishingly loud for their size, and the song is one of the first worth learning — a point made more generally in identifying birds by song.
Feeding them
Sunflower seed, in the shell, is the single most useful offering for this whole group. Suet supports them through cold weather, and peanuts in the shell are taken readily by titmice and nuthatches.
Nyjer is largely wasted on them, since it is aimed at finches. Matching the seed to the birds present is the substance of what to feed birds.
Nest boxes
All of these species use cavities, and all will use a box of the right dimensions with the right hole size.
That makes them the most accessible group for anyone wanting garden birds to breed rather than merely visit, and a box put up in late winter is usually occupied that spring.
Species referenced
Keep reading
- The Small Brown Bird at My FeederFour species account for nearly every one. Look at the breast — plain, blurry or heavily streaked with a central spot — and the answer follows.
- What to Put in a Bird FeederBlack oil sunflower feeds nearly everything. Most mixed seed is filler that gets kicked to the ground, and the cheap bag is not the cheap option.
- Identifying Birds by SoundMost birds are heard rather than seen. Learn rhythm and quality before pitch, start with five species, and use the mnemonics — they work.