The Bird That Matches No Illustration

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

Field guides show adult males, adult females, and sometimes a breeding and non-breeding plate. The birds in a garden in July are frequently none of these.

The recognisable signs of a young bird

The gape. Fleshy pale yellow or whitish corners at the base of the bill, left over from the wide gape a nestling used for feeding. It fades over the first weeks and is the single most reliable indicator.

Loose, fluffy plumage. Juvenile feathers are less densely structured than adult ones, giving a soft untidy look.

Behaviour. Begging with quivering wings, following an adult closely, clumsy landings, and an apparent lack of concern about people.

Short tail. Tail feathers are often still growing, which changes the bird's proportions considerably.

Species that look nothing like the adult

American robin. Heavily spotted below, which reveals it as a thrush and confuses everyone.

European starling. Uniform mouse-grey with a dark bill, so different from an adult that it is regularly reported as an unidentified species. Birds in transition, with a grey head and a spotted black body, look stranger still.

Northern cardinal. Dull brownish with a dark bill rather than the adult's orange one.

Blue jay. Similar to the adult but greyer, with a shorter crest.

European house sparrow. Juveniles resemble dull females and account for many summer sparrow puzzles.

Species Juvenile appearance
American robin Spotted breast, pale scaling above
European starling Plain grey-brown, dark bill
Northern cardinal Dull brown, dark bill
Red-winged blackbird Heavily streaked, like a large sparrow
Chipping sparrow Streaked below, no rufous cap
Cooper's hawk Brown above, brown streaks below

Why late summer is the hardest season

Three things happen at once: juveniles are abundant, adults are moulting and looking scruffy, and song has largely stopped so the easiest identification route is unavailable.

That combination is why experienced birders find July and August harder than March, and it is worth knowing before concluding that identification skills have deserted you.

The moult side of this is covered in why that bird looks terrible.

Using behaviour instead

When plumage fails, watch what the bird is doing.

A juvenile is usually near an adult of its species, and the adult is identifiable. Watching for five minutes to see who feeds it settles far more cases than any amount of comparison with an illustration.

Structure also survives where plumage does not — bill shape, leg length, tail proportions and posture are adult-like from fledging, which is why starting with the bill works on birds that match no plate.

First-winter plumage

After the post-juvenile moult, many species enter a first-winter plumage that is still not the adult one, and some large gulls and raptors take three or four years to reach adult appearance.

Good field guides illustrate these stages for the groups where it matters. Guides that show only adults are the reason so many autumn birds seem to be unrecorded species.

The practical advice

Photograph it. Juvenile plumages are held briefly and change week by week, and a photograph allows an unhurried comparison and a second opinion.

Note the associated adults, the date, and the behaviour. Those three details identify more juveniles than the plumage does.

Fledglings on the ground

A juvenile bird on the ground being fed by parents is the normal state of affairs for many species, and it is the single most common reason people intervene when they should not.

The distinction between a fledgling and a genuinely orphaned nestling is set out in a baby bird on the ground, and it is worth knowing before the situation arises rather than after.

Species referenced

Keep reading