The Squirrel Has Won Again

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

Squirrels are persistent, intelligent and have all day. Any defence based on outwitting them tends to lose.

The geometry that works

Squirrels jump about three metres horizontally and about 1.5 metres vertically, and they climb anything with texture.

So a feeder needs to be more than three metres from any branch, fence, roof or wall, and more than 1.5 metres above the ground, on a smooth metal pole with a baffle below the feeder.

Every part of that is necessary. A pole feeder under a branch is a delivery system, and a baffled pole two metres from a fence is a training exercise.

Measure Works Why
Baffle on a smooth pole Yes Physically blocks the climb
Correct placement Yes Removes the jump
Safflower seed Partly Disliked, not refused
Weight-activated feeder Yes, if well made Closes under a squirrel's weight
Spinning hanger Sometimes Squirrels learn to time it
Greasing the pole No Wears off, and coats the animal
Cage around the feeder Yes Also excludes larger birds

Baffles

The single most effective item, and it must be the right shape and position: a wide dome or cone, at least 45 cm across, mounted below the feeder and high enough that a squirrel cannot jump over it from the ground.

A baffle mounted too low is a step. A baffle too narrow is a handhold.

Seed choice

Safflower is the practical option. Cardinals, chickadees, finches and doves eat it readily; squirrels and grackles largely leave it. Switching costs nothing and reduces pressure noticeably.

Nyjer is also of little interest to squirrels, and it only feeds finches.

Capsaicin-treated seed works on the principle that mammals have receptors for it and birds do not. It is effective and it is also messy, irritating to handle, and restricted in some jurisdictions, so it is not the first thing to reach for.

What does not work

Greasing poles, which wears off, attracts dirt and coats the animal's fur.

Trapping and relocating, which is illegal in many places, usually fatal for the animal, and immediately followed by another squirrel occupying the vacancy.

Most spinning, tilting and jangling contraptions, which entertain for a fortnight while the squirrel works out the timing.

Feeding them separately

A dedicated squirrel feeder with cheap corn, placed well away from the bird feeders, works better than it sounds. A fed squirrel that has an easier option often takes it.

It will not stop a determined animal reaching a poorly placed feeder, and it changes the economics for one that has to work at it.

The birds squirrels bring

Worth noting that a squirrel scattering seed on the ground feeds juncos, doves and sparrows, which do not use hanging feeders anyway.

The nuisance is real and the loss is mostly to the seed budget rather than to the birds.

Rats

The problem worth taking more seriously. Spilled seed under a feeder feeds rats, and in urban areas that is the reason a feeder becomes a complaint.

A seed catcher tray, regular clearing of the ground beneath, and taking feeders in overnight where rats are present address it — and it is the one aspect of feeder management where inaction has consequences for neighbours as well as for the birds, alongside the hygiene points in feeder hygiene.

Accepting some loss

A feeder that is entirely squirrel-proof is usually also inconvenient, expensive or ugly, and most people settle somewhere short of that.

Getting the placement right is the part that repays effort. Everything after that is refinement, and the gadget aisle is largely selling refinement to people whose feeder is hanging under a branch.

Species referenced

Keep reading