Is It a First Edition, and Does It Matter
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
"First edition" is the phrase people reach for, and it is doing less work than they expect. It identifies a printing; it does not confer value. Value comes from demand, and demand is concentrated in a very small number of titles.
Reading the copyright page
Most modern publishers use a number line: a row of digits, often descending, sometimes alternating. The lowest number present indicates the printing.
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 first printing
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 second printing
Some publishers state it plainly — "First Edition", "First Printing", "First published 1957" with no later dates. Others invented their own systems, and several changed systems over the decades, which is why collectors keep publisher-specific reference guides.
| Indicator | Usually means |
|---|---|
| Number line ending in 1 | First printing |
| Lowest number is 2 or higher | Later printing |
| "First Edition" with a number line ending in 5 | Fifth printing of the first edition |
| Book club edition stated | Not a trade first, low value |
| No number line, pre-1950 | Publisher-specific rules apply |
Edition is not printing
An edition is a setting of the type; a printing is one run from it. A book can be a first edition, fifth printing — the same text, printed again because the first run sold. Collectors want the first printing of the first edition, and the number line is what distinguishes them.
The dust jacket is most of the value
For twentieth-century books this is the uncomfortable truth: the jacket is frequently worth more than the book. A first printing of a collected novel might be worth a small amount without its jacket and a great deal with a fine one, because jackets were thrown away and survivors are scarce.
Check that the jacket belongs to the printing. Price-clipped jackets, or jackets from a later printing on a first-printing book, are both common and both reduce value substantially.
Condition dominates
The grading vocabulary is standardised and harsh. "Fine" means as new. "Very good" already implies visible wear. Foxing, a bumped corner, a cracked hinge, an owner's name on the flyleaf — each moves a book down a grade and the value falls steeply with it.
A reading copy of almost anything is worth almost nothing, however early the printing.
Book club editions
Frequently mistaken for firsts because they can carry the same text and similar typography. They are usually smaller, lighter, printed on poorer paper, and have a blind stamp — a small indent — on the rear board. Jackets carry no price.
They are worth very little, and identifying them early saves disappointment.
The realistic position
Most old books are not valuable. Age alone does nothing: a common Victorian volume in poor condition is worth less than a modern paperback. What matters is whether anyone is collecting that author, in that printing, in that condition.
The same logic as is my antique valuable, applied to paper: rarity without demand is not worth anything, and demand is far narrower than people assume.
Points
For collected titles, specific typographical errors or details distinguish the earliest copies from later ones within the same printing. A misspelling corrected partway through the run, a wrong page number, a particular binding colour.
These are called points, and they are title-specific — there is no general rule. Where a book is genuinely collected, a reference guide will list them, and the difference between a copy with the first-state point and one without can be substantial.
Ex-library copies
A book with library markings, a card pocket, a stamped title page or a plastic jacket cover is worth a small fraction of the same book without them. The markings cannot be removed without leaving worse damage.
This catches people out with apparently scarce titles found cheaply: the reason it was cheap is usually visible inside the front cover.
Keep reading
- Is My Antique Valuable? Probably Less Than You HopeAge contributes very little. Condition, originality, maker and demand do almost all of it, and most nineteenth-century objects were made in enormous numbers.
- The Marks That Date an Object ExactlyMost marks give a rough period. Four kinds give a precise year, and they are worth learning because they end the argument.
- What the Movement Tells You, and the Case Does NotCases are swapped, married and replaced constantly. The movement is the clock, and it carries the evidence the case usually cannot.