What the Movement Tells You, and the Case Does Not
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
Clocks are among the most frequently altered antiques, because a movement outlives its case and a good case outlives its movement. Dating the case tells you about the case, and the two may have met last year.
Start with the movement
Take the movement out or look at it through the back door. What you want is the plates, the pillars holding them apart, and any engraving.
Early eighteenth-century movements have thick plates and turned baluster pillars. Later movements have thinner plates and simpler pillars. Mass-produced nineteenth-century American movements are often stamped brass rather than cast, and they look and feel obviously lighter.
Makers frequently signed the movement, the dial, or both, and directories of clockmakers give working dates for thousands of names. A signature is the single most useful thing on a clock.
Winding holes count
| Holes | Means |
|---|---|
| None visible | Weight-driven with no winding, or a timepiece with a pull-wind |
| One | Timepiece only, no strike |
| Two | Time and strike |
| Three | Time, strike and chime, generally later |
A dial with two holes in a case built for a three-train movement is a marriage, and counting holes against the space inside is one of the quickest checks available.
Dials date well
Brass dials with applied chapter rings dominate to about 1770. Painted iron dials — usually called white dials — take over from about 1770 and run through the nineteenth century. Silvered brass appears in between.
Painted dials crack and flake in a characteristic way, and the paint layer is visible at any chip. A pristine painted dial on a clock claimed to be 1780 has probably been restored, which is common and worth knowing about because it affects value.
Signs of a marriage
Fit. The movement should sit on its seatboard with the dial filling the case aperture exactly. Packing pieces, extra screw holes, or a dial that does not quite fill the opening all indicate that something has been made to fit.
Screw holes. Redundant holes in the seatboard or the case sides mean a previous movement of a different size.
Wear that does not match. The case shows wear where a door was opened for decades; the movement shows wear in its pivots. If one is heavily worn and the other is not, they have not been together long.
Height. A longcase clock's weights need a specific fall. A movement in a case that is too short will not run a full week, and evidence of the weights hitting the bottom is a strong sign of a mismatch.
The case is still evidence
Not of the clock's date, but of the case's, and the same furniture characters apply: dovetails, saw marks, screws and secondary woods, as furniture joints and tool marks sets out.
A case that dates to 1790 and a movement that dates to 1790 is a good sign. Two dates fifty years apart is a marriage, and that is a finding rather than a failure — most surviving longcase clocks have been altered at some point.
Before running it
An old clock that has stood for decades should not simply be wound and started. Dried oil turns abrasive, and running a dirty movement wears the pivots quickly and expensively. Have it cleaned first, or leave it stopped, which harms nothing.
American shelf clocks
A large category with its own rules. Mass-produced Connecticut shelf clocks from the 1820s onward carry printed paper labels inside the case, and those labels frequently name the maker, the town and sometimes the patent date.
The label is the best evidence on the clock and the most easily lost, since damp destroys paper. A legible label is worth protecting and should not be cleaned, re-glued or replaced.
Wooden movements, found in some American clocks between roughly 1810 and 1840, are a strong date indicator on their own — the technique was abandoned once brass became cheap enough to stamp.
Keep reading
- The Marks That Date an Object ExactlyMost marks give a rough period. Four kinds give a precise year, and they are worth learning because they end the argument.
- How Reproductions Give Themselves AwayWear in the wrong places, uniformity where there should be variation, and materials that did not exist yet. Fakers concentrate on the front.
- Is It a First Edition, and Does It MatterThe copyright page usually says, in a code each publisher invented for itself. What it means, and why most first editions are worth very little.