How Old Is That Fish?

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

Fish grow throughout life, and the rate varies so much with food and temperature that size is a poor guide to age. What works is counting growth marks.

Why growth leaves a record

Growth slows or stops in winter and resumes in spring. In hard structures — scales, otoliths, fin rays, vertebrae — that produces alternating zones: wide translucent bands from fast summer growth, narrow opaque ones from slow winter growth.

Counting the narrow bands gives years, in the same way tree rings do and for the same reason.

Scales

The traditional method and the only one that does not kill the fish. Take a few scales from below the dorsal fin above the lateral line, clean them, and view them under magnification or in a scale projector.

The growth marks appear as closely spaced ridges. Reading them takes practice, and the method loses accuracy in older fish where the outer rings crowd together, and in species that reabsorb scale material during spawning.

Otoliths

The ear bones, and the more accurate method. They grow continuously, are not reabsorbed, and show clearer annual marks, especially in older fish.

They also require killing the fish, which limits the method to fish being kept or to mortality sampling. Fisheries agencies use otoliths for most serious ageing work for this reason.

Structure Accuracy Kills the fish
Scales Good when young, poor when old No
Otoliths Best overall Yes
Fin rays or spines Good, species-dependent No, if a spine is clipped
Vertebrae Good Yes
Length Poor No

Fin spines

A compromise. A dorsal spine can be clipped and sectioned without killing the fish, and in several species it ages well. This is how walleye and sturgeon are frequently aged in live-release studies.

Why any of this matters

Age structure tells you whether a population is functioning. A lake full of fish that are all the same age is one where spawning has failed for years and the population will collapse when that cohort dies.

A population with fish of many ages, including old ones, is reproducing successfully. That is what managers look for, and it is invisible from catch rates alone.

Growth rate matters too. Stunted populations — many small old fish — usually indicate too many fish for the available food, which is the situation liberal harvest limits are designed to relieve.

The surprising results

Ageing has repeatedly overturned assumptions. Bigmouth buffalo have been aged past a hundred years, making them among the longest-lived freshwater fish known, in a species long dismissed as a rough fish of no interest.

Rougheye rockfish reach over two hundred. Several sturgeon species pass a century. In each case the discovery changed how the species could responsibly be managed, because a fish that takes twenty years to mature cannot sustain the harvest a fast-growing one can.

What an angler can do

Not much precisely, and something usefully. Recording length and weight for fish from the same water over years shows whether the population is growing well or stunting, and reporting tagged fish supports the studies that do the real work.

For identification purposes, size and age are worth keeping separate. A very large individual of a small species is old, not a different species, and the confusion accounts for a fair number of misidentifications discussed in counting fin rays and spines.

Ageing and regulations

Slot limits and minimum sizes are set from age and growth data. A minimum size that lets fish spawn once before they can be kept requires knowing at what length that happens, which requires ageing.

That is why the same species carries different limits in different waters: the growth rate differs, so the length at maturity differs, and a rule copied from a neighbouring state can be wrong for the lake it is applied to.

Species referenced

Why this matters beyond curiosity

  • Look-alike species often carry different limits. Walleye and sauger, black and white crappie, pike and muskie, blue and channel catfish — each pair can have different sizes, seasons and daily limits in the same water.
  • Check it before the fish goes in the livewell. Most of the tests on this site take seconds and are far easier on a fish you are still holding.
  • If you cannot tell, release it. That is the answer that is never wrong, and it is the one a warden will not argue with.
  • Regulations are set by your state or province and change annually. This site identifies fish; it does not tell you the rules. Check the current regulations for the water you are on.

Keep reading