Photographing a Fish So It Can Be Identified

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

The held-toward-the-camera photograph is the standard way anglers photograph fish and the worst possible angle for identifying one.

The problem with the classic shot

Holding a fish out toward the lens exaggerates its size, which is the point. It also foreshortens the body, hides the fins against the hands, and distorts every proportion an identification depends on.

Jaw length relative to the eye, the position of the dorsal fin over the body, the depth of the caudal peduncle — all of these are proportional characters and all are destroyed by the angle.

What works

One true side-on photograph with the whole fish in frame, the camera level with the fish rather than above it, and the fins spread if you can manage it without extra handling.

That single image carries almost every character used in this section: the tooth patch position for walleye or sauger, the jaw extent for bass identification, the fin markings for trout identification, the dorsal spine count for crappie.

Shot Use
Full side-on, level Nearly everything
Head close, side-on Jaw, teeth, cheek scales, mouth position
Dorsal fin spread Spine counts
Mouth open, from front Tooth patches
Held toward camera Almost nothing
From above Almost nothing

Spread the dorsal fin

A folded dorsal fin hides spine counts, and spine counts settle several pairs that nothing else does. Running a wet thumb along the fin base usually raises it briefly.

If the fish is being released, do this in the water or during the same short lift as the main photograph rather than as a separate handling event, for the reasons in handling a fish you intend to release.

Light and background

Direct sun produces glare on wet scales that obliterates markings, which is why so many midday fish photographs show a featureless silver shape.

Shade, or the shadow of your own body, is better. A wet mat or net as a background beats grass, which sticks to the fish and hides the ventral fins.

Include scale

A rod butt, a hand, a measuring mat with markings. Size separates several species pairs and juveniles from adults, and "about two pounds" from an excited angler is not a measurement.

Record the water and the date

More useful than most physical characters. Species ranges are limited and many pairs do not overlap at all, so knowing the lake or river frequently resolves an identification before anything is examined.

Water type helps too: a trout from a warm lowland pond is a different set of possibilities from one in a cold headwater stream.

Then ask

A side-on photograph, the water body, the date and an approximate length is a complete request. The same question with a held-out photograph and no location usually cannot be answered by anyone, however experienced.

Keep the fish wet in frame

A fish that has dried in the air loses colour within a minute or two, and the markings that identify it fade with the moisture. A wet fish photographs its own pattern; a dry one photographs as a pale shape.

Wetting the fish immediately before the photograph both improves the image and reduces handling damage, which is one of the rare cases where the good practice and the good photograph are the same action.

Colour is the least reliable character

Fish colour varies with water clarity, substrate, season, stress and time out of water. The same species from a tannic river and a clear lake can look entirely different, and a stressed fish pales within seconds.

Structure does not vary that way. Fin position, spine counts, scale rows and body proportions are stable, which is why every identification guide on this site leads with them and treats colour as a supporting detail at best.

Video for behaviour

Rarely needed for fish, occasionally useful. Where a fish is being observed rather than caught — spawning behaviour, or a fish visible in clear shallow water — a short steady clip captures fin movement and swimming style that a still frame misses.

Species referenced

Why this matters beyond curiosity

  • Look-alike species often carry different limits. Walleye and sauger, black and white crappie, pike and muskie, blue and channel catfish — each pair can have different sizes, seasons and daily limits in the same water.
  • Check it before the fish goes in the livewell. Most of the tests on this site take seconds and are far easier on a fish you are still holding.
  • If you cannot tell, release it. That is the answer that is never wrong, and it is the one a warden will not argue with.
  • Regulations are set by your state or province and change annually. This site identifies fish; it does not tell you the rules. Check the current regulations for the water you are on.

Keep reading