The Widow With the Spiky Egg Sac
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
Brown widows have expanded rapidly through the southern United States, and in some cities they now outnumber black widows in suburban settings.
The egg sac identifies it
A brown widow egg sac is pale, roughly spherical, and covered in projecting silk spikes — often described as looking like a tiny sea mine.
A black widow sac is smooth, papery and teardrop-shaped.
That single feature is more reliable than anything on the spider, because the spider itself varies enormously in colour while the sac does not.
The spider
Tan to dark brown, with a mottled pattern of lighter and darker markings on the abdomen and often a row of pale spots along the top.
The hourglass on the underside is orange to yellow-orange rather than the black widow's bright red, and it is usually complete.
Colour is not dependable — some individuals are dark enough to be taken for black widows — which is why the sac matters.
| Brown widow | Black widow | |
|---|---|---|
| Egg sac | Spiky, pale, round | Smooth, papery, teardrop |
| Hourglass | Orange to yellow | Bright red |
| Abdomen | Mottled, patterned | Glossy black |
| Behaviour | Very timid, drops and hides | Retreats but defends |
| Web site | Exposed, human-made structures | Sheltered, low, undisturbed |
Where they live
Brown widows favour exposed human-made structures more than black widows do: the underside of garden furniture, mailboxes, meter boxes, patio rails, playground equipment, wheel arches and plant pot rims.
That habit brings them into more frequent contact with people, which is the main reason they get noticed.
Black widow habitat preferences are covered in where black widows live, and the two overlap without occupying quite the same niches.
The risk
Brown widow venom is comparable in potency to black widow venom in laboratory terms, and the practical risk is lower for two reasons: they inject very little, and they are extremely reluctant to bite.
Typical outcomes are local pain and redness, without the muscle cramping and systemic symptoms a black widow bite can produce.
They also drop from the web and play dead when disturbed, which is a behaviour that avoids confrontation rather than inviting it.
Displacement of black widows
In several urban areas brown widows have become abundant where black widows were previously common, and there is evidence they prey on black widow juveniles.
Whether that constitutes displacement is still being worked out. For a household the practical effect is that the widows encountered around a patio in the southern states are increasingly likely to be brown ones.
What to do about them
Check under garden furniture, meter boxes and rails before reaching, particularly in spring when egg sacs are present.
Remove egg sacs mechanically and dispose of them, since each contains a large number of spiderlings.
Wear gloves for work in sheds, under decking and around stored items, which prevents nearly every bite anyone actually receives.
Distinguishing the egg sacs in practice
Egg sacs persist after the spider has moved on, so a patio can be surveyed for them without finding a single spider.
Looking under furniture and rails with a torch takes a few minutes and gives a much better picture of what is present than watching for spiders does, since the sacs are stationary, conspicuous and unambiguous.
Range
Brown widows are established across the Gulf states, through Florida, in southern California, and increasingly in Texas and the south-east, with the range continuing to expand.
They do not tolerate hard freezes, which is what limits them, and their northward spread tracks mild winters rather than any other factor. A widow found well north of that range is far more likely to be a black widow or a false widow, and the ranges in where black widows live are the starting point for working out which is plausible locally.
Species referenced
If you think you were bitten
- Most suspected spider bites are not spider bites. Studies of patients presenting with a “spider bite” repeatedly find that the large majority are bacterial skin infections — frequently MRSA — which need antibiotics rather than reassurance. A spreading, painful, pus-filled sore is far more likely to be an infection than a spider.
- Wash it, ice it, and watch it. Clean the area with soap and water, apply a cold pack, and keep an eye on it.
- Get medical care if the wound spreads or darkens, if you develop cramping, sweating, fever or severe abdominal pain, or if you are confident it was a widow or a recluse.
- Bring the spider only if it is already dead and to hand. Do not go looking for it. Doctors treat symptoms, not species.
In the US, the Poison Help line is 1-800-222-1222. This site is a reference, not medical advice.
Keep reading
- Are There Black Widows Where You Live?Four widow species cover most of the United States between them, and the brown widow is still spreading. The range is far wider than the recluse's.
- Black Widow or Common House Spider? Look UnderneathWidows and house spiders build the same messy web in the same dark corner. The red hourglass underneath is the whole test — plus three backup checks including the egg sac.
- A Black Widow Bit Me. What Actually Happens Next?The realistic timeline, why the pain is muscular rather than local, when antivenom is actually used, and how rare a fatal outcome really is in the United States.