Errors, Varieties and Things That Are Neither
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
Errors are among the most valuable items in philately and among the most misunderstood. The category is narrower than people hope.
What counts as an error
A production failure that escaped the printing works and reached the public. The main types:
Missing colour. One colour of a multicolour design absent entirely.
Inverted centre. In a two-pass printing, one pass applied upside down.
Imperforate. A perforated issue found without perforations, in a pair or larger so the absence is demonstrable.
Wrong paper or watermark. Printed on stock intended for another issue.
Double impression. The design printed twice, offset.
These are rare because postal administrations check for them, and their value follows from that rarity.
What is a variety rather than an error
A consistent difference produced deliberately or by a documented plate state: a re-entry, a plate flaw that appears on one position of every sheet, a shade difference from a separate printing.
Varieties are catalogued and collected, and they are worth modest premiums rather than transformative ones. Plate flaws in particular are collected by specialists position by position.
| Finding | Category | Effect on value |
|---|---|---|
| Missing colour | Error | Large increase, if genuine |
| Inverted centre | Error | Very large |
| Imperforate pair | Error | Large |
| Constant plate flaw | Variety | Modest premium |
| Re-entry | Variety | Modest premium |
| Off-centre | Condition fault | Decrease |
| Colour faded by light | Damage | Decrease |
| Perforations trimmed | Alteration | Serious decrease |
What is neither
Most of what people find.
Off-centre stamps are a condition fault. Perfect centring commands a premium; poor centring reduces value. It is not a variety.
Colour changelings are stamps whose ink has altered through exposure to light, damp or chemicals. They look like colour varieties and are damage.
Ink smears, offsets and misfeeds are usually printer's waste that was supposed to be destroyed, and their status depends on whether the issue is known to have released such material.
Why certification is essential here
The premium on a genuine error is exactly the incentive to manufacture one. Colours can be chemically removed to imitate a missing-colour error; perforations can be trimmed to imitate an imperforate.
Both alterations are detectable by an expert and not by a collector with a magnifier. Anything claimed as an error should carry a certificate from a recognised body, and buying one without is buying the seller's word — the argument set out in forgeries, fakes and why certificates exist.
The realistic expectation
Genuine errors are found, occasionally, by people going through accumulations. It happens rarely enough that it makes news when it does.
The more common outcome is that an apparent error is a known variety worth a small premium, or a condition fault worth less than a normal example. Checking properly before getting attached is the sensible order, and where the value hides covers what actually drives price in ordinary material.
Freaks
A third category sitting between varieties and damage. A freak is a one-off production oddity — a paper fold producing a blank streak, a misregistered colour, a partial perforation shift.
Freaks are collected, they are not catalogued individually because each is unique, and their value is whatever a collector of that issue will pay. They are usually modest and occasionally striking.
The distinction from an error is repeatability: an error is a defined failure that produced a known quantity of items, a freak is a one-off accident.
Where to check before believing
Catalogues list known errors and varieties for each issue, and specialist society literature goes further. If what you have is genuine, it will almost certainly be described somewhere already, because errors that escaped are noticed and recorded.
Finding no reference at all is more often a sign that the item is damage or a freak than that you have discovered something new.
Topics referenced
Keep reading
- Where the Value Hides in Identical-Looking StampsTwo stamps from the same design can differ by three orders of magnitude. The difference is almost never visible in the design.
- Forgeries, Fakes and Why Certificates ExistPrinting method catches most classic forgeries. Overprints, regumming and repairs need an expert, and any expensive stamp should carry a certificate.
- How the Stamp Was Printed, and How to TellRun a fingertip across the design. Engraved stamps have raised ink you can feel; lithographed ones are flat. That single test separates most printings.