Pressed or Cut? The Edge Tells You

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

Both produce a faceted, sparkling surface, and from across a room they look alike. The difference is how the pattern got there: cut glass is ground away from a blank by hand, pressed glass is moulded into shape while molten.

The fingernail test

Run a fingernail slowly across the pattern.

Cut glass edges are sharp. The nail catches on each ridge with a distinct click, because the facets were ground with an abrasive wheel and meet at crisp angles.

Pressed glass edges are rounded. Molten glass flows into a mould and surface tension softens every corner, so the nail glides across without catching.

This is the whole test and it is reliable enough to settle most cases in a second.

Mould seams

Pressed glass was made in a mould, and moulds come apart. Look for fine raised lines running vertically up the piece, usually two opposite each other, sometimes three.

Cut glass has no seams because the blank was blown and the pattern ground afterwards. A seam anywhere on the body means moulding.

Seams tell you more than that, and dating glass by the seam covers how far up the piece the seam runs and what that dates.

Cut Pressed
Edges Sharp, catch a nail Rounded, smooth
Mould seams None Usually visible
Pattern base Cut clean through Rounded where it meets the body
Sound Long clear ring Duller
Weight Often heavy, lead content Variable
Facet interiors Very slightly matte, polished Glossy as moulded

The ring

Tap the rim gently with a fingernail. Good cut glass with a high lead content rings with a sustained clear note that carries for a second or more.

Pressed soda glass gives a shorter, duller sound. This is a lead-content test rather than a cutting test — the two correlate because cut glass was usually made from lead crystal, which is softer and cuts cleanly.

Hold the piece loosely by the base when doing this, since gripping it damps the ring.

Combination pieces

Some glass is both, and this trips people up. A pressed blank can be finished with hand cutting, particularly around the rim or on a few prominent facets, producing a piece with mould seams and some sharp edges.

Look at the whole object rather than one area. If most of the pattern is soft and a few features are sharp, it is pressed glass with cut highlights, and it is valued accordingly.

Polished pontil marks

Under the base of hand-blown glass there is often a pontil mark, a rough or ground circular scar where the rod was attached during making. Better pieces have it ground and polished smooth, leaving a shallow polished depression.

Pressed glass has no pontil, because it never hung from a rod. A polished pontil depression under a faceted piece is a strong indication of hand production, and it is one of the first things a dealer checks.

What this is worth knowing for

Cut glass represents skilled hand labour and is priced accordingly; pressed glass was made in quantity and mostly is not. The exceptions are early or rare pressed patterns collected for their own sake, which is a specialist field where the general rule stops applying.

For anything found in a house clearance, the fingernail test answers the question that matters before any further research is worth doing.

Modern reproduction

A great deal of "cut crystal" sold in the twentieth century is pressed glass with a cut-look pattern, and some of it is very convincing at a glance. The fingernail test defeats all of it, because no moulding process produces a genuinely sharp edge.

Acid-polished pressed glass is the closest imitation: after moulding, the piece is dipped in acid to gloss the surface, which mimics the brightness of cutting. The edges remain rounded, so the test still works.

Damage and value

Chips on the rim of cut glass are common and reduce value substantially, and they can be ground out by a restorer at the cost of altering the profile. Run a finger round the rim before buying: chips are easier to feel than to see, particularly on a heavily patterned piece.

Keep reading