The Cat and the Bird Feeder
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
This is one of the few areas of garden bird care where the evidence is strong and the popular remedies are weak.
The scale
Peer-reviewed estimates put annual bird mortality from cats in the United States in the billions, with unowned and feral cats accounting for the larger share.
The precise figures are debated, and the order of magnitude is not. Cats are among the largest direct human-associated causes of bird death, alongside window collisions.
Individual owners often find this hard to reconcile with a cat that rarely brings anything home. Cats consume most of what they catch and bring back a small fraction, so what appears on the doormat substantially understates the total.
What actually reduces it
Keeping the cat indoors. Complete, and the option many owners will not take. Indoor cats also live longer.
A brightly coloured collar cover. These work because birds have excellent colour vision and see a bright ruff long before they register a cat. Trials show large reductions — far larger than bells.
Keeping the cat in at dawn and dusk, when both hunting activity and bird activity peak.
Playing with the cat and feeding a meat-rich diet. A trial found both reduced hunting measurably, apparently by satisfying the same drives.
| Measure | Effect |
|---|---|
| Indoor only | Complete |
| Bright collar cover | Large reduction |
| Meat-rich diet, daily play | Meaningful reduction |
| Dawn and dusk confinement | Moderate |
| Bell on a collar | Small |
| Feeder placement alone | Small |
| Cat deterrent devices | Variable, often temporary |
Feeder placement
Not a solution, and worth getting right anyway.
Feeders should be either well clear of cover — more than two metres from anything a cat can hide behind — or immediately adjacent to dense thorny cover a bird can dive into. The dangerous arrangement is the middle case: a feeder a metre from a shrub gives the cat concealment and the bird no escape.
Ground feeding is the highest-risk arrangement, and where cats are present it is worth moving that seed onto a raised platform.
Bird baths
Same principle. A bath on open ground with a clear view around it is much safer than one against a hedge.
The wider context
Cats are one of several avoidable causes, and window collisions are of comparable magnitude — the subject of a bird hit my window.
Someone who wants their garden to be good for birds will get more from addressing both than from either alone, and both are within an individual's control in a way that habitat loss is not.
An injured bird
A bird caught by a cat needs veterinary attention even if it looks unhurt. Cat saliva carries bacteria that cause fatal infection within days, and a bird released after a cat encounter usually dies of that rather than of its wounds.
The correct action is a wildlife rehabilitator, promptly, and antibiotics are the treatment. Releasing it into a hedge is well intentioned and generally fatal.
Talking about it
This subject generates more heat than any other in garden birding, and it is worth separating the animal from the argument. Cats do what cats do.
The measures that work are cheap, undramatic and available to any owner, and the collar cover in particular asks very little for a large effect.
Someone else's cat
The awkward case, and there is less available. Motion-activated sprinklers work while they are novel, scent deterrents work poorly, and physical barriers along fence tops help in some gardens.
Beyond that the productive route is a conversation about collar covers, which asks the owner for very little and is the measure with the best evidence behind it.
Species referenced
Keep reading
- A Bird Hit My Window. What Now?Most stunned birds recover if left alone in a dark, quiet box. And the fix for the window is on the outside of the glass, which is why most products fail.
- What to Put in a Bird FeederBlack oil sunflower feeds nearly everything. Most mixed seed is filler that gets kicked to the ground, and the cheap bag is not the cheap option.
- Water Brings More Birds Than SeedWater attracts species that never touch a feeder, and most bird baths are too deep, too slippery and in the wrong place.