The Fish Worth Reporting
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
A small number of introduced fish are worth reporting when found outside their established range, because early detection is the only stage at which anything can be done. Each has a character that confirms it.
Northern snakehead
Long cylindrical body, a long soft dorsal fin running nearly the whole back with no spines, a large toothed mouth, and large scales on top of the head.
Confused with: bowfin, which is native and should not be reported. The separation is the anal fin — a bowfin's is short, a snakehead's is long, running much of the underside. Bowfin also have a bony plate under the jaw and, in males, an eyespot at the base of the tail.
Silver and bighead carp
Silver carp are the jumping ones. Both have very small scales, an upturned mouth, and eyes set noticeably low on the head — below the level of the mouth, which no native fish shows.
Confused with: gizzard shad. Shad are much smaller, have a distinct dark shoulder spot in young fish, and lack the low-set eye.
Round goby
Small, bottom-dwelling, with a distinctive fused pelvic fin forming a single suction disc under the body. That fused fin is diagnostic.
Confused with: native sculpins, which have two separate pelvic fins. Turning the fish over settles it immediately.
| Species | Confirming character | Confused with |
|---|---|---|
| Northern snakehead | Long anal fin, scaled head | Bowfin |
| Silver/bighead carp | Eye below mouth level | Gizzard shad |
| Round goby | Single fused pelvic disc | Sculpin |
| Sea lamprey | Round jawless sucking mouth | Native lampreys |
| Grass carp | No barbels, short dorsal | Common carp |
Sea lamprey
Jawless, eel-like, with a round sucking disc of teeth in place of a mouth. Native lampreys exist and several are harmless filter feeders as adults, so the tooth arrangement in the oral disc is what separates them — a job for a photograph and an expert rather than a field call.
Report an eel-like fish with a sucking disc and let the agency sort it.
What to do
Photograph it side-on, as photographing a fish describes, with something for scale and a clear view of the fins.
Note the water body and the exact location. Coordinates from a phone are ideal.
Check the local regulations on returning it. Several jurisdictions prohibit returning listed invasive species alive, and a few require them to be killed. This varies and it is worth knowing before you are standing on the bank deciding.
Report through the state or provincial fisheries agency. Most run a dedicated line or app, and a photograph with coordinates is what they need.
What not to do
Do not move a fish between waters, alive or dead, and do not empty a bait bucket into a lake. Bait bucket transfer is one of the main vectors for several of these species.
Do not assume a strange fish is invasive. Native species are frequently reported by mistake, and the confusions above are the common ones. A photograph and a report is the right response either way, and letting the agency decide costs nothing.
Cleaning gear between waters
More important than any single report. Several invasives spread as larvae, eggs or fragments in bilge water, live wells, waders and nets rather than as adult fish anyone would notice.
The standard advice is clean, drain, dry: remove visible material, drain every compartment that holds water, and let gear dry completely before using it elsewhere. Zebra mussel veligers and several fish pathogens survive in a damp net and not in a dry one.
Felt-soled wading boots are prohibited in several jurisdictions for exactly this reason, since felt holds water and organisms far longer than rubber.
Established versus new
A report matters most where the species is not yet established. Reporting a common carp from a river that has held them for a century achieves nothing; reporting one from a water where they have never been recorded may matter a great deal.
Agencies publish distribution maps, and checking whether a species is already known from your water takes a minute and makes the report useful.
Species referenced
Why this matters beyond curiosity
- Look-alike species often carry different limits. Walleye and sauger, black and white crappie, pike and muskie, blue and channel catfish — each pair can have different sizes, seasons and daily limits in the same water.
- Check it before the fish goes in the livewell. Most of the tests on this site take seconds and are far easier on a fish you are still holding.
- If you cannot tell, release it. That is the answer that is never wrong, and it is the one a warden will not argue with.
- Regulations are set by your state or province and change annually. This site identifies fish; it does not tell you the rules. Check the current regulations for the water you are on.
Keep reading
- Where the Fish Are Tells You What They AreDepth, current, temperature and structure each narrow the species list before a fish is caught. Habitat is a character like any other.
- Handling a Fish You Intend to ReleaseMost release mortality comes from three avoidable things: air exposure, dry hands, and hooking depth. Each has a simple fix.
- How Old Is That Fish?Fish lay down growth rings in scales and ear bones. Reading them is how fisheries managers know whether a population is healthy, and length alone tells you almost nothing.