Weighing a Rock Properly
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
Density separates minerals that look alike, and unlike colour it cannot be faked by staining or coating.
Why it is diagnostic
Specific gravity is how many times heavier a specimen is than the same volume of water. It is fixed by composition and structure, so any clean sample of a mineral gives the same number.
Most of the common rock-forming minerals sit between 2.6 and 3.0, which is why a specimen well outside that range is immediately interesting.
| Mineral | Specific gravity |
|---|---|
| Quartz | 2.65 |
| Calcite | 2.71 |
| Feldspar | 2.55–2.76 |
| Barite | 4.5 |
| Pyrite | 5.0 |
| Magnetite | 5.2 |
| Galena | 7.5 |
| Gold | 19.3 |
The measurement
Weigh it dry. Note the figure to a tenth of a gram.
Put a cup of water on the scale and zero it. The scale should now read zero with the water sitting on it.
Suspend the specimen fully in the water without letting it touch the cup. Thread or fine wire works; the specimen must be completely under and hanging free.
Read the scale. That number is the mass of water displaced, which for water is numerically the specimen's volume in cubic centimetres.
Divide. Dry weight divided by the displacement reading is the specific gravity.
A 26.5 g quartz pebble displaces about 10 g of water, giving 2.65.
Where it goes wrong
Porous specimens. Anything that soaks up water gives a low reading, because the water fills the pores rather than being displaced. Sandstone, pumice and weathered material are all unreliable.
Trapped bubbles. A bubble clinging to the specimen adds volume and lowers the answer. Tip the specimen while submerged to shake them off.
Small specimens. Below a few grams the errors swamp the result on a kitchen scale. Use the largest clean piece available.
Mixed rocks. The method measures whatever is in the water, so a specimen of two minerals gives an average that matches neither.
The heft test
Experienced collectors judge density by hand, and it works better than it should. The reason is that the eye estimates volume well and the hand estimates weight well, so a mismatch registers immediately.
Barite is the classic case: a pale, dull, unremarkable-looking mineral that feels wrong in the hand because it is far heavier than anything that colour has any business being. That single impression identifies it more often than any other test.
Where it settles arguments
Gold and pyrite, most usefully. Pyrite is 5.0 and gold is 19.3, which is a difference nothing else in the comparison approaches — and it is the reason panning separates them at all. The rest of that comparison is in gold and pyrite.
It also catches the heavy sulphides that look like ordinary grey rock. A dull grey specimen at 7.5 is galena, and nothing common is anywhere near it.
What it does not do
It will not price anything. A high specific gravity indicates heavy elements, which is interesting geologically and says nothing about value — the position set out in is my rock valuable holds here as everywhere.
A simpler version
For a quick comparison rather than a number, weigh two specimens of similar size against each other in the hands. The absolute figure does not matter if the question is only whether this piece is heavier than a known quartz pebble of the same size.
That answers the practical question most of the time — is this unusually dense, or is it ordinary — and it takes no equipment at all.
Recording it
Write the number down with the specimen. Specific gravity is one of the few properties that does not change with cleaning, weathering or time, so a figure measured once stays valid, and it is worth having when a specimen is looked at again years later with better references to hand.
Mineral pages referenced
Keep reading
- Gold vs Pyrite: Six Tests That Settle It in Two MinutesSix field tests that separate real gold from pyrite, chalcopyrite and mica — using a knife, a ceramic tile and your hands. No chemicals required.
- Is My Rock Valuable? An Honest AnswerMost rocks are worth nothing, and that is fine. Here is what actually creates value in a specimen, the handful of finds worth pursuing, and how to get a real appraisal.
- Is This Amber, Copal or Plastic?Four tests separate real amber from its two common substitutes, and one of them can be done with tap water and salt in under five minutes.