Is This Amber, Copal or Plastic?

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

Three materials are involved and they get progressively harder to separate, which is why the tests have to be run in order.

Salt water first

Dissolve about two tablespoons of salt in a cup of warm water until no more will dissolve, then drop the piece in.

Amber floats or hovers. Copal floats. Most plastics — and glass, and stone — sink.

This one test removes the large majority of substitutes, costs nothing, and does no damage. Rinse and dry the piece afterwards.

Material Salt water Warm to touch Acetone drop UV
Amber Floats Yes No effect Blue-white glow
Copal Floats Yes Turns tacky Strong pale glow
Polystyrene Sinks No Dissolves Often none
Glass Sinks No No effect Usually none
Modern resin Sinks Slightly Varies Varies

The touch test

Amber is a poor conductor and reaches skin temperature quickly, so it feels warm within a second or two. Glass and stone pull heat out of the finger and stay cold.

It is a genuine test and an easy one, and it separates the glass imitations that the salt water already caught — useful as a cross-check rather than as evidence on its own.

Separating amber from copal

This is the hard one, because copal is real resin and behaves like amber in nearly every simple test.

Acetone. A drop of nail polish remover on an inconspicuous spot, left for thirty seconds and wiped. Copal softens and becomes tacky; amber is unaffected. This is mildly destructive and should be done on an edge or the reverse.

Hardness. Copal is softer and a fingernail sometimes marks it, where amber will not be marked.

Inclusions. Copal is young enough that its inclusions are modern species, and it frequently contains far more of them than amber does — a piece packed with unusually well-preserved insects is more likely copal than an exceptional amber.

What the UV test shows

Both fluoresce, so this does not separate amber from copal. It does separate both from most plastics, which fluoresce differently or not at all.

Baltic amber typically shows a blue-white glow; copal shows a paler, often stronger one.

Why it matters

Amber is a fossil resin tens of millions of years old and is priced accordingly. Copal is thousands of years old and worth a small fraction. Plastic is worth nothing.

Because they look alike, the market for imitations is substantial, and inclusions in particular are faked — an insect embedded in modern resin is straightforward to produce and sells for a great deal to someone who did not run the tests.

The wider point in is my rock valuable applies here more sharply than usual: material that looks valuable and is easy to imitate attracts imitation.

When to get an opinion

Anything with a significant inclusion, and anything being bought at a real price. Both are worth showing to a dealer who handles amber, because the tests above establish that a piece is resin and do not establish how old it is beyond the acetone check.

Pressed amber

A third category worth knowing about: genuine amber fragments heated and compressed into a larger piece. It is real amber, passes every test above, and is worth considerably less than a single natural piece of the same size.

The tell is internal — swirled flow lines and flattened bubble discs where the fragments fused. Backlighting a piece and looking for a pattern that flows rather than sits still is the usual way to spot it.

Mineral pages referenced

Keep reading