How Worried Should You Be About False Widows?

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

False widows occupy an awkward middle ground: not harmless in the way a cellar spider is, and nothing like the newspaper version.

What they are

Spiders in the genus Steatoda, related to true widows and sharing the same untidy tangle-web construction.

Several species are widespread in Europe and North America, and Steatoda nobilis — the noble false widow — has expanded its range substantially over recent decades, which is what generated the coverage.

Recognising one

A bulbous, glossy abdomen, dark brown to nearly black, often with a cream or pale band across the front and a pattern some describe as a skull.

Shorter, stockier legs than a true widow. No red hourglass anywhere.

The web is a messy three-dimensional tangle, usually in a window frame, a wall corner, under a sill, or in a shed or garage.

False widow True widow House spider
Hourglass Absent Red, on the underside Absent
Abdomen Glossy, banded, patterned Glossy black, rounder Dull, mottled
Legs Short, stout Long, thin Long, thin
Web Untidy tangle Untidy tangle, strong Untidy tangle
Concern Minor Genuine but manageable None

Distinguishing them from true widows matters more than distinguishing them from house spiders, and the widow comparison is in black widow or house spider.

What a bite does

Local pain, comparable to a wasp sting, with swelling and redness for one to three days. Some people report warmth and stiffness around the area.

Serious outcomes are documented but rare, and much of the alarming coverage involves wounds that were bacterial infections — often Staphylococcus — attributed to a spider without the spider being seen.

That attribution problem is general and is worth understanding before accepting any bite claim, including one's own, which is the argument in spider bite or infection.

Why the coverage is disproportionate

The species is spreading, it looks like something dangerous, and the story has an appealing shape. School closures and hospital reports make headlines; the far larger number of uneventful encounters does not.

The result is a spider that most people in its range have lived alongside for years without incident being treated as a novel hazard.

When to see a doctor

For any bite that develops spreading redness, increasing pain after the first day, discharge, fever or a red streak moving away from the site.

Those are signs of infection rather than of venom, and infection is what actually needs treating. That is true regardless of what caused the original break in the skin.

Living with them

They stay in their webs, they do not wander into beds, and they bite only when pressed against skin — typically in clothing or bedding brought in from a shed.

Removing webs from frequently used doorways and window frames reduces contact. Shaking out gardening gloves and boots stored in a garage prevents most of the rest.

Beyond that, a false widow in a shed is a spider in a shed, and the appropriate response is the same as for any other, using the method in getting spiders out alive.

Other Steatoda species

The noble false widow gets the attention, and several smaller relatives are far commoner and entirely unremarkable.

Steatoda grossa, the cupboard spider, is widespread indoors and is a dark, glossy, slow spider that most people have in a garage without ever noticing. Steatoda bipunctata is smaller again and lives in sheds and under sills.

None of them behave differently from the noble species and none warrants a different response, which is worth knowing before an identification to species is treated as important.

They eat widows

Steatoda species are known to prey on true widows where the two overlap, taking them in their own webs.

That is a reasonable argument for leaving a false widow in an outbuilding alone, particularly in areas where black widows are common.

Species referenced

If you think you were bitten

  • Most suspected spider bites are not spider bites. Studies of patients presenting with a “spider bite” repeatedly find that the large majority are bacterial skin infections — frequently MRSA — which need antibiotics rather than reassurance. A spreading, painful, pus-filled sore is far more likely to be an infection than a spider.
  • Wash it, ice it, and watch it. Clean the area with soap and water, apply a cold pack, and keep an eye on it.
  • Get medical care if the wound spreads or darkens, if you develop cramping, sweating, fever or severe abdominal pain, or if you are confident it was a widow or a recluse.
  • Bring the spider only if it is already dead and to hand. Do not go looking for it. Doctors treat symptoms, not species.

In the US, the Poison Help line is 1-800-222-1222. This site is a reference, not medical advice.

Keep reading