Which Birch? Bark Colour Is Not Enough
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
Birch is the tree everyone can name and few can name precisely. "The white one" covers several species, one of which is not a birch at all.
Start by ruling out aspen
Quaking aspen has smooth pale bark, often greenish-white, and it grows in the same northern habitats. It is not a birch and the differences are clear once looked for.
Aspen bark does not peel. Birch bark does, in horizontal strips, on every species to some degree. Aspen bark carries dark diamond-shaped marks where branches were; birch carries horizontal lenticels, short dashes running around the trunk.
The leaves settle it absolutely. Aspen leaf stalks are flattened side-on, which makes the leaves flutter in almost no wind and gives the tree its name. Birch stalks are round and the leaves hang still.
The four birches
| Paper birch | River birch | Grey birch | Yellow birch | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bark | Chalky white | Salmon to cinnamon | Dull greyish-white | Bronze-yellow |
| Peeling | Wide horizontal sheets | Ragged curling strips | Barely | Fine curls |
| Habitat | Cool uplands, north | Floodplains, wet ground | Poor dry soil, disturbed | Cool moist forest |
| Trunks | Often single | Usually multi-stemmed | Often clumped, leaning | Single |
| Twig smell | Faint | Faint | Faint | Wintergreen |
The two easy ones
River birch is the one that is not white. Salmon, tan and cinnamon, peeling in ragged papery curls, and it grows in wet ground — floodplains, stream banks, damp gardens. Nothing else looks like it. It is also the most planted birch in warm regions because it resists bronze birch borer.
Yellow birch gives itself away by smell. Scrape a twig and it smells strongly of wintergreen. The bark is a distinctive bronze-gold, peeling in fine tight curls rather than sheets, and it is a forest tree rather than a garden one.
The two white ones
Paper birch and grey birch are the pair that actually get confused.
Paper birch is chalky bright white, peels in broad horizontal sheets that can be pulled off in strips, and the inner bark revealed underneath is orange. It is a northern tree, and it can reach a substantial size.
Grey birch is duller, more greyish-white, and does not peel readily. It has distinct black triangular patches below where each branch joins the trunk. It grows on poor dry disturbed soil, usually in clumps of several leaning stems, and it stays small.
The black triangles are the quickest test: prominent on grey birch, faint or absent on paper birch.
Do not peel the bark
Worth saying plainly. Bark peeled from a living birch does not grow back, and the scar is permanent and can admit disease. Loose bark that has already lifted is fine to look at; anything still attached should stay attached.
Fallen branches and dead trees give you all the bark you need for identification, and birch bark persists long after the wood inside has rotted, which is why hollow birch bark tubes are a common woodland sight.
Where to go next
Habitat narrows this group faster than most. Wet ground points to river birch, poor dry disturbed ground to grey birch, cool northern forest to paper or yellow. Run the tree through the key with the bark character and the habitat together, since either alone leaves ambiguity these four do not deserve.
European white birch, in gardens
One more turns up in plantings: European white birch, often sold as silver birch. It is white-barked like paper birch but develops rough black fissured bark at the base of older trunks while staying white above, which no native North American birch does.
Its twigs droop noticeably at the tips, giving the whole tree a weeping look that paper birch lacks. In gardens and parks it is the likelier white birch; in northern forest, paper birch is.
Species referenced
Start here: opposite or alternate?
Look at where the leaves join the twig. Are they in matched pairs directly across from each other, or staggered one after another? The vast majority of trees are alternate, so finding an opposite tree removes almost everything else in one step.
In North America, opposite-leaved trees are remembered as MAD Cap Horse: Maple, Ash, Dogwood, Caprifoliaceae (viburnums and elders), and Horse chestnut. That is very nearly the whole list.
Check partway along a healthy twig rather than at the tip, where crowding can make alternate leaves look paired. And check more than one twig.
Keep reading
- Cedar, Juniper or Arborvitae? None of Them Are CedarsScale-leaved conifers all look like the same green fan from a distance. Three genera get called cedar in North America and only one of them is one.
- White Oak or Red Oak? The Lobes Have Points or They Do NotEvery oak in North America falls into one of two groups, and one character separates them. It holds for leaves, acorns and timber alike.
- What Tree Did This Nut Come From?Nuts and their husks are the most specific thing a tree drops. A dozen types cover almost everything you will find on the ground in eastern North America.