Cedar, Juniper or Arborvitae? None of Them Are Cedars
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
Scale-leaved conifers are the hardest group to name casually, because they all resolve to the same impression: a dense evergreen with flat green sprays instead of obvious needles. Three genera in common cultivation account for almost all of them, and the names in use are actively misleading.
Nothing here is a cedar
True cedars are Cedrus: cedar of Lebanon, Atlas cedar, deodar. They have needles in dense rosettes on short spurs, they are large and spreading, and they are not native to the Americas.
Everything called cedar in North America is something else. Eastern red cedar is a juniper. Western red cedar is a thuja. Northern white cedar is a thuja. Alaska yellow cedar is a chamaecyparis. The naming happened because the timber smelled and behaved like cedar, and it stuck.
This matters for identification because looking up "cedar" produces information about a genus you are almost certainly not holding.
The three you will actually meet
| Juniper | Arborvitae (Thuja) | Chamaecyparis | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foliage | Scales, often with sharp juvenile needles mixed in | Flat sprays, one plane | Flat sprays, finer |
| Fruit | Blue berry-like cone | Small brown woody cone | Small round woody cone |
| Crushed smell | Sharp, gin | Sweet, medicinal | Resinous, varies |
| Underside markings | None obvious | Faint | Distinct white X or butterfly |
| Habit | Often irregular, shrubby to conical | Narrow conical | Conical, often drooping tips |
The tests that work
Look at the fruit. A juniper's berry-like cone is unmistakable — blue-purple with a waxy bloom, soft rather than woody, and present for most of the year on female plants. Nothing else in this group makes anything resembling a berry.
Crush the foliage. Juniper smells of gin, which is not a coincidence: juniper berries are what gin is flavoured with. Arborvitae is sweeter and more medicinal.
Turn a spray over. Chamaecyparis species usually show distinct white markings on the underside where the stomata are, often in a butterfly or X shape between the scales. Arborvitae shows this faintly or not at all.
Check if it is flat. Arborvitae sprays are strictly flat, arranged in one plane like a fan. Juniper foliage goes in all directions.
Juvenile foliage
Junipers produce two kinds of leaf. Mature growth is scale-like and soft; juvenile growth is needle-like and sharp, and many junipers keep both on the same plant, especially on vigorous shoots and on shaded interior branches.
A plant with both sharp needles and soft scales is almost certainly a juniper. Nothing else in this group does it, and it is a strong confirmation when the fruit is absent.
Why so many are planted
These three genera tolerate shearing better than almost any other conifer, which is why hedges and foundation plantings are full of them. That also means the specimen you are looking at may have been clipped into a shape that removes every useful habit character.
If the plant has been sheared, work from foliage and fruit alone and ignore the shape entirely — the shape is the gardener's, not the tree's.
Where this leaves you
For a hedge or a garden conifer, checking for berries and crushing a sprig settles it in about ten seconds. For anything wild in eastern North America with blue berries and mixed needle and scale foliage, eastern red cedar is by far the likeliest answer.
Needle-leaved conifers are a separate problem with a separate test, covered in pine, spruce or fir, and the two groups are worth keeping apart mentally because nothing transfers between them.
Species referenced
Start here: opposite or alternate?
Look at where the leaves join the twig. Are they in matched pairs directly across from each other, or staggered one after another? The vast majority of trees are alternate, so finding an opposite tree removes almost everything else in one step.
In North America, opposite-leaved trees are remembered as MAD Cap Horse: Maple, Ash, Dogwood, Caprifoliaceae (viburnums and elders), and Horse chestnut. That is very nearly the whole list.
Check partway along a healthy twig rather than at the tip, where crowding can make alternate leaves look paired. And check more than one twig.
Keep reading
- Which Birch? Bark Colour Is Not EnoughEveryone knows the white one. Four birches are common in eastern North America and only one is reliably white, which is where the confusion starts.
- Ash or Walnut? Count the Leaflets, Then Crush OneBoth have long compound leaves that look alike from below. Leaflet count, arrangement and smell separate them, and one of the three is unmistakable.
- White Oak or Red Oak? The Lobes Have Points or They Do NotEvery oak in North America falls into one of two groups, and one character separates them. It holds for leaves, acorns and timber alike.