Mold in a Rented Home

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

Disputes about mold in rented homes almost always come down to one question: is this a building defect or a lifestyle issue? Everything else follows from the answer.

What points to a defect

Growth on an external wall or in a corner at the coldest point of a room, which indicates a cold bridge or missing insulation.

Growth with no obvious moisture source in the room, particularly on a ground floor or near the floor.

A bathroom or kitchen with no extractor fan, or one that does not vent outside.

Windows that cannot be opened, or have no trickle vents.

Damp appearing after rain, which points at the building envelope.

A tide mark low on the wall, which suggests rising damp or a failed damp course.

What points to use of the property

Growth confined to one poorly ventilated room where drying laundry is routine. Windows never opened in a well-fitted modern flat. Furniture hard against a cold external wall with no air gap. Heating turned off entirely in winter, leaving surfaces cold.

In practice most cases are a combination, and the useful framing is that a building should be capable of being lived in normally without growing mold.

Evidence Value in a dispute
Dated photographs over time High
Written reports and replies High
Humidity and temperature logs High
A surveyor's or environmental health report Very high
A verbal complaint Very low
An air spore test Low — see below

Documenting it properly

Photograph the growth with something for scale and a visible date, and repeat monthly. A sequence showing spread is far more persuasive than a single image.

Report in writing every time — email or a letter — and keep the replies. A phone call that was not followed up in writing did not happen, as far as any later process is concerned.

Log temperature and relative humidity with an inexpensive meter. Readings showing that the room is heated and ventilated and still humid shift the argument considerably.

Note anything the landlord has said, and any repairs promised and not made.

Air tests are not the answer

Commercial spore sampling is frequently suggested and rarely decides anything, for the reasons in mold testing kits: spores are present everywhere, and a count without a comparison establishes little.

A surveyor's report identifying the physical cause — a failed seal, a cold bridge, an unvented bathroom — carries far more weight than any air sample.

Escalating

Most jurisdictions have a route beyond the landlord: an environmental health department, a housing ombudsman, a tenancy tribunal, or a local authority housing standards team.

They generally expect the tenant to have reported the problem in writing first and to have allowed a reasonable period for repair, which is another reason to start the paper trail early.

What tenants can do meanwhile

Ventilate deliberately — short periods of wide opening rather than a window on the latch all day. Heat the property to a consistent moderate temperature rather than in bursts. Dry laundry outside or in a vented tumble dryer. Keep furniture a few centimetres off external walls. Wipe condensation from windows in the morning.

None of that resolves a genuine defect, and doing it all removes the argument that the growth is caused by how the property is used — which is what the dispute usually turns on, and which is set out in more detail in condensation and window mold.

Health claims

Worth keeping separate from the repair question. A repair obligation generally rests on the condition of the property rather than on proving a health effect, and framing a complaint around illness often makes it harder to resolve rather than easier.

Report the defect, document it, and keep any medical matters as a separate record. What the evidence supports about health effects is set out in toxic black mold, and overstating it tends to undermine an otherwise strong case.

Types referenced

The species matters less than you think

  • Public health guidance is to remove all indoor mold regardless of type. The CDC and EPA do not recommend routine species testing for ordinary households, because the response does not change: find the water, stop it, remove the growth.
  • “Toxic black mold” is a marketing phrase, not a category. Stachybotrys is real and does need soaked material to grow, so finding it tells you something useful about your building. But the health effects that are well established — allergy, asthma aggravation, irritation — are not specific to it.
  • Mold without water does not persist. Cleaning growth while leaving the moisture source is why it comes back. The leak, the condensation or the ventilation is the actual problem.

Call a professional for areas larger than about 10 square feet, for anything in HVAC ductwork, after sewage or flood water, or if anyone in the household is immunocompromised or has a lung condition.

Keep reading