Why the Tree Outside Your House Is Not in the Field Guide
By IdentifyThese Editorial · · 3 min read
People trying to identify a tree in front of their house often work through a field guide and find nothing that fits. The guide is not wrong; it is answering a different question.
Two different sets of trees
A field guide to trees describes the species that grow in a region naturally. A street is planted deliberately, by people choosing from a nursery catalogue, and the criteria have nothing to do with what grows there wild.
Street trees are chosen for tolerating compacted soil, road salt, drought, pollution, restricted root space and hard pruning. Very few forest species tolerate any of that, so the planted palette is small, repetitive and frequently non-native.
The usual suspects
| Tree | Recognised by |
|---|---|
| London plane | Mottled peeling bark, cream and olive |
| Norway maple | Milky sap in the leaf stalk when broken |
| Littleleaf linden | Heart-shaped leaves, papery bract on the fruit |
| Honeylocust | Tiny leaflets, often thornless and podless cultivars |
| Callery pear | White spring flowers, glossy leaves, awful smell |
| Ginkgo | Fan-shaped leaves, unmistakable |
| Red maple | Paired keys, red twigs and buds |
| Bradford pear | A callery pear cultivar, splits in storms |
Seven or eight species cover most of what you will see, and once learned they are recognisable everywhere because the same catalogue is used everywhere.
Cultivars complicate it
Many street trees are named cultivars, selected and propagated clonally: a seedless honeylocust, a columnar maple, a non-fruiting ginkgo. These can differ substantially from the wild species in shape, leaf colour or fruiting, while remaining that species.
So a tree that keys out as a honeylocust but lacks the ferocious thorns the guide describes is still a honeylocust — it is a thornless cultivar, which is the only kind anyone plants near a pavement.
The Norway maple test
Norway maple is one of the most planted and most misidentified street trees, constantly taken for sugar maple. There is a definitive test: break a leaf stalk and a drop of milky white sap appears at the break. Sugar maple sap is clear.
It takes five seconds and it is conclusive, which makes it worth knowing given how common the confusion is.
Ginkgo, the easy one
Fan-shaped leaves with no midrib, often notched in the middle, arranged in clusters on short spurs. Nothing else looks remotely like it, and the tree is a living fossil with no close relatives.
Street plantings are almost always male, because female ginkgos drop fruit that smells strongly of vomit. A ginkgo dropping foul fruit in autumn is a female that was planted before anyone could sex a sapling reliably.
Where a key still helps
The tree key covers the species that turn up in both settings, and works from characters rather than from where the tree is growing. If a street tree keys to something implausible for your region, the answer is usually a cultivar or a non-native, and the character that matched is still telling you the right family.
Age tells you what was fashionable
Street plantings happen in waves, so the age of a neighbourhood predicts its trees. Streets planted in the 1960s and 1970s across North America are heavy with Norway maple; the 1990s brought callery pear everywhere; recent plantings favour diversity deliberately, after Dutch elm disease and emerald ash borer both demonstrated what a monoculture street costs.
A row of identical trees of identical size was planted at once, which is itself a clue: it means a single species chosen by one authority in one year, and looking up what that city planted then often answers the question faster than a key.
When the tree is young
Most identification characters develop with age. Bark in particular is nearly useless on a sapling, since almost every young tree has smooth grey bark regardless of what it will become.
On young street trees, work from leaves, buds and twigs instead, which are adult characters from the start. That is also what the tree key leans on, for exactly this reason.
Species referenced
Start here: opposite or alternate?
Look at where the leaves join the twig. Are they in matched pairs directly across from each other, or staggered one after another? The vast majority of trees are alternate, so finding an opposite tree removes almost everything else in one step.
In North America, opposite-leaved trees are remembered as MAD Cap Horse: Maple, Ash, Dogwood, Caprifoliaceae (viburnums and elders), and Horse chestnut. That is very nearly the whole list.
Check partway along a healthy twig rather than at the tip, where crowding can make alternate leaves look paired. And check more than one twig.
Keep reading
- What Tree Did This Nut Come From?Nuts and their husks are the most specific thing a tree drops. A dozen types cover almost everything you will find on the ground in eastern North America.
- Identifying a Tree by Its BarkBark changes with age, which is why most bark guides fail. Work with texture, direction and colour under the surface rather than matching a photograph.
- Leaf Shape, Properly: Lobed, Toothed, EntireEvery tree key asks whether the margin is lobed, toothed or entire, and whether the leaf is simple or compound. Here is what those four words actually mean.