Buds and Twigs, Which Work All Year
By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read
Buds get overlooked because leaves are more obvious, and they are the better character in almost every way. They are present for eight months rather than four, they do not vary with sun exposure the way leaves do, and several species have buds so distinctive that nothing else is needed.
What to look at
Arrangement. Opposite or alternate, exactly as with leaves, because buds sit where leaves were. This is the first and most useful cut, and it works on a bare twig in January.
Colour. Frequently diagnostic. Copper, red, black, green, grey — birds and mammals aside, few things in winter woodland are coloured at all, so a coloured bud stands out.
Shape and size. Long and pointed, short and rounded, flattened, angular.
Scale count. How many overlapping scales cover the bud, and whether they are arranged in a visible pattern.
Terminal bud present or absent. Some species have a true terminal bud at the twig tip; others abort it and the twig ends with a lateral bud beside a small scar.
The ones worth learning
| Tree | Bud |
|---|---|
| American beech | Very long, slender, sharp, copper — unmistakable |
| Ash | Black, opposite, sooty-looking, blunt |
| Sugar maple | Sharp-pointed, brown, opposite, many scales |
| Red maple | Rounded, red, opposite, few scales |
| Red oak group | Clustered at the twig tip, sharply pointed |
| White oak group | Clustered at the tip, blunter, often hairy |
| Sycamore | Cone-shaped, encircled by the leaf scar |
| Norway maple | Large, green-brown, blunt, opposite |
Beech and ash alone are worth the effort. Beech buds are so distinctive that identification is instant at any distance where the twig is visible, and black ash buds are the only truly black buds in most of the range.
Oak clusters
Oaks put several buds together at the very tip of each twig rather than spacing them out. That cluster is diagnostic for the genus before you look at anything else, and it works in winter when the group question — white or red — has to be answered from bud shape and bark rather than leaf bristles.
Leaf scars
Below each bud is the scar where last year's leaf detached, and inside the scar are small marks where the vascular bundles ran into the leaf. Their number and arrangement is species-specific.
Walnut has a large scar with a distinctive shape often compared to a monkey face. Sycamore's leaf scar completely encircles the bud, which no other common tree does. Ailanthus has enormous heart-shaped scars.
A hand lens helps but is not essential for the large ones.
Cutting a twig lengthwise
The pith inside is another character, and it takes a knife and a second. Walnut and butternut have chambered pith — a ladder of hollow spaces separated by partitions — which nothing else common has.
Most other trees have solid pith, either round or, in oaks, distinctly star-shaped in cross-section.
Where this fits
Buds are the reason winter identification is not the hard problem it is assumed to be. Between bud arrangement, bud shape and bark, most trees are identifiable without a leaf in sight, and the characters are more stable than the leaves people rely on in summer.
When to collect
Buds are formed by midsummer, so from about August onward the following spring's buds are already present and fully formed. That means bud characters are available even while the tree is in full leaf, and a twig collected in September shows the same buds you would find in January.
Late spring is the one gap. Once buds have opened they are gone, and the twig carries expanding shoots instead. Between roughly April and July, work from leaves.
Handling a twig
Take a short piece from a lower branch rather than a vigorous water sprout. Fast vertical shoots from the base of a tree produce atypical buds, larger and more widely spaced than normal, and they mislead. Ordinary lateral growth from the outer canopy is what field guides describe.
Species referenced
Start here: opposite or alternate?
Look at where the leaves join the twig. Are they in matched pairs directly across from each other, or staggered one after another? The vast majority of trees are alternate, so finding an opposite tree removes almost everything else in one step.
In North America, opposite-leaved trees are remembered as MAD Cap Horse: Maple, Ash, Dogwood, Caprifoliaceae (viburnums and elders), and Horse chestnut. That is very nearly the whole list.
Check partway along a healthy twig rather than at the tip, where crowding can make alternate leaves look paired. And check more than one twig.
Keep reading
- Identifying Trees in Winter, With No Leaves at AllBark, buds, twigs and last year's fruit on the ground. Winter identification is not harder than summer — it just uses different characters, several of them more reliable.
- Identifying a Tree From a Photograph: What Actually WorksPhoto identification succeeds and fails in predictable ways. Which four photographs to take, and why a picture of the whole tree is the least useful of them.
- Which Birch? Bark Colour Is Not EnoughEveryone knows the white one. Four birches are common in eastern North America and only one is reliably white, which is where the confusion starts.