The Breeds Ordinary Cats Get Mistaken For

By IdentifyThese Editorial · Reviewed · 3 min read

Five breeds account for most of the misidentification in cats, and the pattern is the same in each case: the trait people use to recognise the breed is common in the general cat population.

The five, and why

Maine Coon. Recognised by size and a long dense coat, both of which occur widely in random-bred cats. Long hair is a common recessive, as longhair or shorthair explains, and large cats are simply common.

Russian Blue. Recognised by an even grey coat and green eyes. Grey is one of the most ordinary cat colours there is, produced by a dilute variant of black that is widespread. Your grey cat is probably not a Russian Blue covers it.

Siamese. Recognised by points and blue eyes. The pointed gene is present across the random-bred population and pointed moggies are common, particularly in some regions.

Bengal. Recognised by spots, which occur through several routes in ordinary cats. Bengal, or a spotted cat from down the road covers the separation.

British Shorthair. Recognised by a round face and dense coat on a stocky body, which describes a great many ordinary cats too.

Breed Trait people use Why it fails
Maine Coon Size, long coat Both common in random-bred cats
Russian Blue Grey coat Dilute black is ordinary
Siamese Points, blue eyes Pointed gene is widespread
Bengal Spots Spotted tabby occurs independently
British Shorthair Round face, stocky Describes many ordinary cats

What actually separates a breed cat

Consistency across the whole animal. A pedigree cat conforms to a standard in body proportion, head shape, ear set, coat texture, eye shape and colour together, because it was bred to.

A random-bred cat resembling a breed usually matches on one or two features and not the rest. A large fluffy cat with a Maine Coon's coat and a round domestic head is a large fluffy cat.

So the test is not whether one feature matches, but whether all of them do — and that is a judgement that takes familiarity with the standard rather than a photograph comparison.

Why cat DNA tests help less than dog tests

Dog breeds have been closed populations for long enough to be genetically distinctive, and dog DNA tests can assign ancestry with reasonable confidence.

Cat breeds are younger, smaller and were founded from local random-bred populations very recently in genetic terms. Several breeds are still barely distinguishable from the regional cats they came from, so a test frequently reports a breed group rather than a breed, or nothing at all. Do cat DNA tests actually tell you the breed covers the detail.

The honest answer

Most cats are not a breed and there is nothing lacking in that. Breed cats are a small minority of the population, and the traits that make a cat handsome are distributed throughout the species rather than concentrated in registries.

Most cats are not a breed makes the case at length, and this piece is its specific application: the resemblance is real, and it is a resemblance rather than an ancestry.

Where the claim comes from

Frequently from a rescue or a previous owner rather than from any assessment. A cat listed as a Maine Coon mix at a shelter has usually been described that way by someone looking at it for a few seconds, exactly as shelter breed labels describes for dogs.

The label then travels with the animal and becomes part of its story, and by the time anyone questions it there is a photograph, a name and three years of family belief attached.

Does it matter?

For most owners, not at all. The cat is the same animal either way, and nothing about its care changes.

It matters in two situations. Where money changes hands — a kitten sold as a breed at a breed price should come with registry paperwork, and without it the buyer is paying for a description. And where a breed carries a specific health risk worth screening for, such as the cardiac conditions screened in some pedigree lines.

Outside those, the accurate answer is interesting rather than consequential, which is a reasonable place for it to sit.

Breeds referenced

Keep reading